Ask A Cartographer

Assigning Road Segments to Point Data

November 08 2010 | 0 comments
Categories: Map Data, Symbology

Hello,

Thank you for the input. I downloaded the tutorial on how Hot Spot Analysis Works and was excited to try it and then realized my license must not come with the Hot Spot Analysis Tool because it is not in the toolbox.

In your reply you had said that there are a number of ways to assign each road segment the accident data. I would like to try this solution. How would I go about doing this?

Thanks again. Your help is greatly appreciated!

The answer to your question: Analyzing Bike/Ped Crash Data is below. It is also posted on the Mapping Center Archive at http://mappingCenter.esri.com/index.cfm?fa=ask.answers&q=1623. We hope this helps you!
Your Question:
Analyzing Bike/Ped Crash Data
I would like to analyze the location of about 320 bicycle and pedestrian crashes in a city over a 6 year period. About 2/3 of the points have XY values. The other third, I manually placed using a description of the location. I would like to display the locations in a more meaningful way than just points. Would I be able to do a dot density map or some type of heat map? Attached is a map I found in another plan. Is it possible to replicate this in GIS? The points all have dates associated with them. I have Arc10 and went to the training and wrote down "generate schematics." I do not have much experience with the spatial analysis tools and am not even sure what that means. Any and all suggestions are most welcome.
Our Answer:
The method shown in your attachment uses lines of varying width to represent the number of accidents on each segment of the road network. You can do this if you have a numeric attribute for each road segment that identifies the number of accidents for each. Then you can use the Quantities - Graduated Symbol renderer on the Symbology tab of the Layer Properties.



Below is an example in which I used the FlowClass attribute to show the amount of flow in each river segment.



Since you have point data, you would have to assign each road segment the accident data that is contained in the points. There are a number of ways you can do this – if this is the solution you want to try, let us know and we can tell you how to go about this.

On the other hand, you mention a heat map approach, which I take to mean a density surface. That is a raster solution that would result in a surface that tells you how many points fall in a neighborhood around each sell in the raster. Below is an example in which I mapped the density of cities along the rivers.



You also mention a dot density map – that is not the solution since that is a way to symbolize polygons based on a numeric value (see our blog entries on this on Mapping Center). You do not have polygon data so you do not need to consider this mapping method.

You also mention schematics – that is probably overkill for what you are trying to achieve here. There are easier and more straight forward ways to achieve a good looking and communicative map for your data. For example, you say that you do not want to simply map the points, but such a map, in which you simply map the location of each point, can be very illuminating. To display overlapping points so that they can be seen, use a casing (a thin outline in a different color) on the symbol.

Having said all that, I encourage you to look at some of the tools in the spatial statistics toolbox as these may provide an even better solution. There are several short videos to get you started at bit.ly/spatialstats. You could, for example, use the hot spot analysis tool to create a map showing statistically significant hot/cold spots. Given that you have 6 years of data, you could also use the new temporal mapping tools to animate the distributions over time. If you use the Hot Spot Analysis tool, you will want to aggregate your point data before running the analysis. Strategies for doing this are discussed in Learn more about how Hot Spot Analysis works (see the section titled Hot Spot Analysis Considerations).
Attachment: http://fileUpload.esri.com/MappingCenter/ask/11-2-10/elizab/PedAccidentMap.pdf

Mapping Center Answer:

The spatial statistics tools are available at all license levels from ArcView to ArcInfo.  The tool is called Hot Spot Analysis -- it is located in the Spatial Statistics toolbox in the Mapping Clusters toolset.  To learn more about it you can also check out this new forum for spatial statistics questions.

Note that you do not need to assign the accident data to the road segments to use this tool. Instead you will aggregate the point data into polygon areas.  You can find strategies for this in the section titled Hot Spot Analysis Considerations in the online help topic How Hot Spot Analysis works.

The need to assign the accident data to the road segment is only if you want to make a map like the one you originaly sent us a picture of.  If that is what you want to do, let us know and we can give you some ideas about hwo to do this.

If you would like to post a comment, please login.

Contact Us | Legal | Privacy |